Signs It’s Time to Switch to a Different Pacifier Shape

Ever find yourself sneaking into your baby’s room at 2 AM, desperately searching for that missing pacifier under the crib? Been there, mama. And if your infant pacifier keeps falling out, it might be time to switch things up.

Not all pacifiers are created equal, and just like babies outgrow their newborn onesies in the blink of an eye, they also outgrow certain pacifier shapes. So if your little one suddenly starts rejecting their favorite binky or constantly losing it, let’s chat about whether it’s time for an upgrade.

1. The Pacifier Keeps Falling Out—ALL. THE. TIME.

Listen, I don’t know how many times I’ve played the “Where’s the pacifier?” game in the middle of the night, but it’s too many. If your baby’s pacifier just won’t stay in their mouth, it could be a sign that the nipple shape isn’t working for them anymore.

Here’s why that might be happening:

• The pacifier is too small for their growing mouth.
• The nipple shape isn’t giving them a good latch anymore.
• They’re ready for a different style that better fits their age.

One thing that saved my sanity? The Ingy Bingy Band, a pacifier wristband—a total game-changer. It keeps the pacifier attached to their wrist, so when it falls out, it’s still right there. No more scavenger hunts at nap time!

2. Suddenly Refusing Their Pacifier?

If your baby used to be obsessed with their pacifier but now acts like you’re offering them broccoli instead, it could be the shape. As they grow, their mouth changes, and what was once the perfect fit may now feel weird to them.

Try switching to an orthodontic pacifier or a different style—sometimes a simple shape change makes all the difference. And while you’re at it, attach it to a pacifier clip or that handy pacifier wristband so it doesn’t keep disappearing into the baby abyss.

3. Teething Turns the Pacifier Into a Chew Toy

Teething babies are on a mission to chew everything, including their pacifier. If they’re gnawing on it instead of sucking, it might be time to upgrade to a teething-friendly version.

And if you’re dealing with the constant “drop-and-cry” cycle, trust me—a pacifier wristband like the Ingy Bingy Band keeps it close and stops you from having to wash it 47 times a day.

4. Oral Development Changes

Okay, real talk—pacifiers can affect teeth and jaw development over time. If your baby is getting their first teeth, it’s worth switching to an orthodontic pacifier that supports natural alignment.

5. Thumb-Sucking Is Taking Over

If your baby ditches the pacifier for thumb-sucking, it could mean their binky isn’t cutting it anymore. While thumb-sucking is natural, it’s way harder to wean off than a pacifier. Switching to a more comfortable pacifier shape might help keep them interested in it instead of their fingers.

Keep That Pacifier Close—Because Who Has Time to Search for It?

No matter which pacifier you choose, keeping it with your baby is key. The Ingy Bingy Band has been a lifesaver—it keeps the pacifier attached to their wrist, so when they need it, it’s always right where they need it whenever they need it. No clips, no lost binkies, no unnecessary wake-ups.

So, mama, if your infant pacifier keeps falling out, your baby is rejecting it, or teething is making things complicated, try a new shape—and grab a pacifier wristband while you’re at it. You’ll thank me at 2 AM when you’re not crawling under the crib!

 

 

The Ingy Bingy Band is not your everyday pacifier clip! This game-changing pacifier wristband helps babies self-soothe at a younger age than ever before! Instinctively, babies gnaw on their hands in an attempt to soothe. The Ingy Bingy pacifier wristband keeps their pacifier right where they’ll find it, allowing your baby to comfort and calm themselves while you do whatever it is you need to do!

Our buttery soft wristband comes in two styles to accommodate every pacifier.

Our Pacific style should be used when your baby’s pacifier holes are near their nose and chin when in use. It is most commonly used with Avent, BIBS, Dr. Brown’s, MAM, Nuby, NUK, Medela, FRIGG, Nanobébé, Tommee Tippee, and Chicco pacifiers. 

Our Sequoia style should be used when your baby’s pacifier holes are near their nose and chin when in use. It is most commonly used with Itzy Ritzy, Ryan & Rose, and The Dearest Grey pacifiers.  

If you are still unsure which pacifier wristband style is right for you, check out our style guide or text the name and/or picture of your preferred paci & we’ll let you know which style is right for you!